Unpaid Test Task: What Can an Employer Ask?
8 min read · Updated November 5, 2026
By Bogdan
In short
An unpaid test task is usually lawful when it is short, simulated and only used to judge your skills. A trial day or shift where you do real work under instructions is, in the UK, Germany, France and the Netherlands, generally treated as work that has to be paid at least the minimum wage. A take-home assignment has no specific rule, but the work stays yours: an employer has no right to use it unless you agree. And a probation period is not a test at all: it is paid employment, capped at six months in most cases under EU law.
Unpaid test tasks: when a test turns into free work
In early November 2026, two very different news stories made the same complaint. A commentary published by China News Service on 4 November asked how interview "homework" could be stopped from becoming free labour, after applicants described being asked to produce business plans, designs, data analyses and even complete real projects. Two days earlier, Russian job seekers interviewed by the regional news site E1.ru described test tasks — a social-media analysis, a content strategy, posts and edited video due within days — that they saw as a cover for unpaid work, with some vacancies reposted after the work was handed in.
Neither story is from the EU, but the practice is familiar everywhere. Recruiters use three different things that candidates often lump together, and the law treats them differently:
- A take-home assignment or case study: you work on your own time and send something back.
- A trial day, trial shift or work trial: you come in and work alongside the team before an offer.
- A probation period: you have been hired, and the first months of the contract are a trial.
Trial days and trial shifts: the rules by country
There is no single EU rule on unpaid trial days. National courts and governments ask the same basic question, though: were you being tested, or were you working?
- United Kingdom. The government's minimum-wage guidance says the law doesn't define a trial work period, and that a person asked to do a "trial", "test" or "recruitment exercise" may still be a worker entitled to the minimum wage. Factors include whether the trial is genuinely for recruitment, how closely you are observed and whether your work has value to the employer beyond testing you. In the government's view, work in a trial lasting longer than one day is likely to be paid at the minimum wage in all but very exceptional circumstances; a trial of a few hours may be reasonable unpaid.
- Germany. Courts distinguish an unpaid "Einfühlungsverhältnis" — a short visit where you have no duty to work and the employer cannot give you instructions — from "Probearbeit", which is an employment relationship. In decided cases, three days of bakery shifts in work clothes and three days in a call centre with fixed workflows were employment. Legal commentators put the limit for an unpaid trial at a few days, a week at most; where real work is done, pay is owed, and the statutory minimum wage (€13.90 an hour since 1 January 2026) applies.
- France. An "essai professionnel" is a test before hiring. The official labour-code portal says it must be short and is in principle unpaid, unless a collective agreement provides otherwise. The Cour de cassation accepted a few hours of letter-typing by a secretary candidate as such a test (16 September 2009); a longer test under normal working conditions is generally treated as work.
- Netherlands. In March 2024 a Dutch court upheld a fine against an employer that did not pay two people for a "proefdag" (trial day), ruling that leaving a trial day unpaid amounts to 100% underpayment of the minimum wage — although it cut the fine as disproportionate.
Elsewhere the answer depends on your country's minimum-wage and employment law. A useful rule of thumb across Europe: watching, shadowing and a short supervised exercise can be unpaid; serving customers, working a full shift or producing something the business uses is work.
Take-home assignments: how long, and who owns the work?
No European law sets a maximum length for a take-home assignment, and because you do it at home without being directed, it rarely counts as employment. What protects you here is copyright.
Under EU copyright law, the author of a work — a text, a design, a strategy document, code — holds the exclusive right to authorise its reproduction. The EU Software Directive gives an employer the economic rights to a program only when it is created by an employee in the execution of their duties or following the employer's instructions. A candidate is not yet an employee, so in principle the work you submit remains yours, and the company needs your permission to use it.
In practice, a reasonable assignment usually looks like this:
- It takes a few hours, not days, and the time is stated in advance.
- It uses a fictional or past case, or anonymised data — not a live client brief.
- It is given to shortlisted candidates, not to everyone who applies.
- It comes with an explanation of how it will be assessed, and is discussed with you afterwards.
Probation is not a test task: it is paid employment
A probation period ("période d'essai", "Probezeit", "proeftijd") happens after you have been hired. You are an employee, you are paid your salary, and either side can usually end the contract more easily than later on.
EU Directive 2019/1152 on transparent and predictable working conditions limits probation to six months in most cases, with longer periods allowed only exceptionally where justified by the nature of the job or in the worker's interest. National limits can be shorter: in France, for example, probation on a permanent contract lasts at most two months for workers and employees, three for supervisors and technicians and four for managers, and it can be renewed once.
So if an employer proposes an "unpaid probation" of several weeks, that is not a probation period in the legal sense. It is unpaid work.
Red flags that a test task is free work
- The task is a real, current problem of the company: "redesign our homepage", "write next month's posts", "analyse our sales data".
- It would take more than a working day, or the deadline only works if you treat it as a full-time job.
- You're asked to sign over the rights to what you submit, or to deliver editable source files ready for use.
- Everyone who applies gets the same large task, before any interview.
- No feedback, or the role is reposted soon after you hand in the work.
- A "trial shift" where you serve customers, work the till or take a full shift on the rota without pay.
Take-home tasks can also be a security risk: if an assignment asks you to download and run code or install software, check it first — fake recruiters use "test tasks" to deliver malware.
How to negotiate a test task without losing the job
You can ask questions about a test task without seeming difficult. Recruiters expect them from serious candidates.
- Ask how long the task is expected to take and how it will be assessed.
- Offer a time-boxed version: "I can spend three hours on this; here's what I'll prioritise."
- Suggest an alternative: a portfolio piece, a past project you can walk through, or solving the case live in the interview.
- For a large task, ask whether it is paid. Some employers pay for assignments of a day or more.
- Put a note on your submission that it's provided for assessment only, and keep a dated copy.
If the trial was real work and wasn't paid, you can usually claim the minimum wage for those hours — through your country's labour inspectorate or employment tribunal. Keep messages, dates, hours and the names of the people who supervised you.
How to handle an unpaid test task
- 1
Identify what you're being asked to do
Is it a take-home assignment, a trial day or shift, or a probation period? The rules differ for each.
- 2
Ask for the time and the criteria
Ask how long it should take, how it will be assessed and whether it will be discussed with you.
- 3
Check the task for red flags
Real company problems, multi-day work, rights transfers or running unknown software are signs it's more than a test.
- 4
Set a limit or propose an alternative
Offer a time-boxed version, a portfolio piece or a live exercise, and ask whether longer tasks are paid.
- 5
Keep a record
Keep a dated copy of what you sent, plus messages, hours and who supervised you during any trial.
- 6
Claim pay if it was real work
If a trial day or shift was actual work, contact your labour inspectorate or employment tribunal about the minimum wage owed.
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to do an unpaid test task?
No — it's your choice, but the employer may then choose another candidate. You can ask for a shorter version, propose a portfolio piece or a live exercise instead, or ask whether a long task is paid. Many employers accept a reasonable counter-proposal.
How long should a take-home assignment take?
No law sets a limit. A few hours is common for a fair assignment; a task that needs more than a working day, or a real client deliverable, is a sign that it's free work rather than a test. Ask for the expected time before you start.
Is an unpaid trial day legal?
It depends on what you do. A short visit where you observe or do a supervised exercise can be unpaid. Real work under the employer's instructions — a shift, serving customers — is generally paid work in the UK, Germany, France and the Netherlands, at least at the minimum wage. The UK government's view is that a trial longer than one day is likely to require the minimum wage.
Can a company use the work I did for a test task?
Not without your permission. Under EU copyright law, the author holds the rights to their work, and the rule that gives employers the rights to software only covers employees. Note on your submission that it's for assessment only, and keep a dated copy.
Is a probation period the same as a trial?
No. A probation period starts after you've been hired: you're an employee and you're paid. Under EU Directive 2019/1152 it is generally limited to six months. An "unpaid probation" is not a probation period in the legal sense.
Sources
- China News Service — Commentary on unpaid interview assignments as free labour (4 November 2026) ↗
- E1.ru — Job seekers send hundreds of applications but can't find work (2 November 2026) ↗
- GOV.UK — Calculating the minimum wage: eligibility (unpaid work trial periods) ↗
- LAG Rheinland-Pfalz, 5 August 2015 — 7 Sa 170/15 (Einfühlungsverhältnis vs Probearbeit) ↗
- Haufe — Probearbeit und Schnuppertage: was Arbeitgeber beachten müssen (case law overview) ↗
- BMAS (German Federal Ministry of Labour) — Mindestlohn ↗
- Code du travail numérique — Qu'est-ce qu'un essai professionnel ? ↗
- Cour de cassation, chambre sociale, 16 September 2009, n° 07-45.485 (Légifrance) ↗
- Service-Public.fr — Période d'essai d'un salarié en CDI ↗
- Rechtbank Oost-Brabant, 21 March 2024, ECLI:NL:RBOBR:2024:1136 (unpaid trial day) ↗
- Directive (EU) 2019/1152 on transparent and predictable working conditions, Article 8 (EUR-Lex) ↗
- Directive 2009/24/EC on the legal protection of computer programs, Article 2 (EUR-Lex) ↗
- Directive 2001/29/EC on copyright in the information society, Article 2 (EUR-Lex) ↗
Ready to build your CV?
Create a professional, ATS-ready CV in minutes — free, no sign-up to start.
Build my CV — free